Government Overzealousness in Texas -- Again

In Texas, do they arrest every man in town when an anonymous caller claims she was beaten and raped by her husband? Or round up all the women in town and place them in protective custody? I think not. Do they collect all the children in town based on a tip that one has been physically abused? Well, probably not -- yet. But that is essentially what the Texas government did at the FLDS compound in Eldorado.

I'm going on record. The FLDS raid will blow up in the Texas Child Protective Service's face like the Waco raid did in Janet Reno's face -- but maybe not literally this time.

It's not apparent that they have any real specific evidence of abuse other than the existence of pregnant teenage girls. But what town can you go to in this country and not be able to find pregnant teenage girls? Even if the authorities are holding some evidence, what is the likelihood that it applies to every child (or adult) in the compound?

The state took custody of all the toddlers. Did they think the toddlers were in imminent danger of being taken to the (spiritual) marriage bed? The state took custody of all the boys. Did they think the boys were any more likely to be abused than any other boy in the state? (I'd be surprised if the FLDS tolerates homosexuals.) Did they justify taking them because they thought the boys were being trained to become abusers? If so, a raid on any church in the state that, for example, teaches boys that they will be the head of their households and that a woman's place is in the home is not that far away.

How can Texas apply such a broad brush to this problem without violating the individual constitutional rights of the children and their parents? I can see that Texas had the right to investigate the call from the 16-year-old girl. But even if they found some evidence of abuse of specific children during the investigation, I don't see how they could legally take children that weren't being abused. I see lots of law suits coming.

Don't get me wrong. I have little sympathy for the adult members of that cult. I'm thinking about all those little children who have been torn away from their parents. I don't believe the stories about the kids not knowing who their parents are. They've been taught to keep details of their lives secret. Anyway, if what we hear in the news is correct, kids not knowing their daddies is becoming the norm across the country.

Update: This has happened before, and it turned out pretty much like I'm thinking this incident will. Read CNN's account of a similar raid in 1953.

---

Comments

Make a comment:

Name (required) Email (required, but not published) Website (optional) Comment (required)